‘Google tax’ gets closer in Germany – but don’t expect any money to change hands

Germany’s ‘Leistungsschutzrecht‘ – an addendum to German copyright law that governs how aggregators can reuse media companies’ content – last week cleared its second legislative hurdle and is now on its way to becoming law.

The addendum passed Germany’s upper house on Friday.

Surprisingly, the SPD, Germany’s biggest opposition party and a former opponent of the Leistungsschutzrecht, didn’t use its power to stop the highly controversial proposal. Instead, Peer Steinbrück, the party’s challenger for the post of chancellor in Germany’s upcoming general election, is promising to “get rid of the broken law” if he gets elected and the SPD gains the majority in parliament. 

One of the reasons Steinbrück believes the Leistungsschutzrecht is broken has to do with the current version. Initially intended to protect media outlets and publishing houses against unlicensed use of their content, it developed into something nicknamed the ‘Google tax’. It would have forced aggregators like Google News or Bing News to pay for using ‘snippets’ – short introduction texts that media companies use as teasers.

In the current version, this stipulation has been completely removed, allowing news aggregators to again use snippets and quotes for free, but any more than that and they may end up having to pay publishers. The downside: the law doesn’t define the length of a snippet, a legal loophole that will have to be closed by lawyers.

A victory for publishers?

Despite more than a year of heated discussion, the law changes nothing for companies like Google or Microsoft – a clear win for the aggregators over the publishers. Germany’s publishers, however, are trying to sell the new law as a win. According to the publishers’ organisation VDZ, the law “acknowledges the accomplishments of publishing houses for the first time”.

Freischreiber, an organisation that represents freelance journalists in Germany and an opponent of the Leistungsschutzrecht, sees the new law as a threat to freelancers. “It creates legal uncertainty for freelancers,” the organisation says on its blog. For example, it is not yet clear how the law will influence secondary use of articles. Most freelance journalist sell articles more than once to make up for reduced budgets of publishing companies.

International media experts and venture capitalists have also criticised the new law. Media pundit Jeff Jarvis said: “I am disappointed that the land of Gutenberg, the land that invented the ability to share knowledge and ideas at a mass scale and to empower speech is now haggling over the control and ownership of a few words. As they say in German, schade. What a shame.” Albert Wenger of Union Square Ventures (whose investments include Twitter, Kickstarter and Tumblr) writes on his blog: “I agree that the LSR is the wrong approach because it is a blunt instrument that will have significant collateral damage.”

The new law still needs to be signed by the German federal government and the German president, Joachim Gauck, to become a fully-fledged law. While it’s still possible that the president will withhold his signature, it’s highly unlikely in reality.

Via: http://www.zdnet.com/google-tax-gets-closer-in-germany-but-dont-expect-any-money-to-change-hands-7000013152/

Posted in Technology. Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.

Related Posts:

Not really ‘flat rate’? German court trips up Deutsche Telekom’s throttling plans

Whistleblower Snowden may testify against the NSA in Germany

Germany brings anti-spying bill to the UN, meets with US intelligence

Comments are closed.

Search Classified Listings

  • Breaking News

  • Weather for Berlin

    Today Friday Saturday Sunday Monday
    It is forcast to be Partly Cloudy at 11:00 PM CEST on July 31, 2014
    Partly Cloudy
    It is forcast to be Partly Cloudy at 11:00 PM CEST on August 01, 2014
    Partly Cloudy
    It is forcast to be Chance of a Thunderstorm at 11:00 PM CEST on August 02, 2014
    Chance of a Thunderstorm
    It is forcast to be Chance of a Thunderstorm at 11:00 PM CEST on August 03, 2014
    Chance of a Thunderstorm
    It is forcast to be Chance of a Thunderstorm at 11:00 PM CEST on August 04, 2014
    Chance of a Thunderstorm

  • Most Viewed past 3 days:


    Get your free daily horoscope + free daily forecast below.
    Choose your zodiac sign:
    March 21 - April 19
    September 23 - October 22
    April 20 - May 20
    October 23 - November 21
    May 21 - June 20
    November 22 - December 21
    June 21 - July 22
    December 22 - January 19
    July 23 - August 22
    January 20 - February 18
    August 23 - September 22
    February 19 - March 20

    Latest Classifieds

    The forecast for berlin, germany by WP Wunderground